Week 13 Prompt Response
In 2005, I began working at a public library and within a few months became the head of children’s and teen services. I set out to read as much YA and juvenile fiction as I could and fell in love with both. I had a front row seat to the Twilight craze and the Hunger Games popularity. We regularly had adults looking for YA books at our library, and our collection was Ah-Mazing (takes a bow for collection development.) I am always ready to recommend a YA title to adults; in fact, I often have a hard time not recommending at least one YA title to adults because I just have more experience with those titles. My go-to question in this type of RA conversation would be “Are you open to the idea of any YA/young adult books?” If they are, great, if not at least for now I won’t annoy them with YA suggestions.
New Adult literature is not a “genre” that I am yet well-versed in. I see the usefulness of it as a step beyond YA for those young adults who don’t want to read YA anymore (although, I think anyone can read good YA). The ability to differentiate between books about teens and books about young adults ages 18-26 is now a must, and being familiar with the most popular authors and series is something I will pay more attention to. I am anxious now to get my hands on a few titles so that I can explore the nuances of NA beyond the misconception that it is just about sex (Cataldi, 2015). NA Alley talks about the importance of honesty in these titles which translates to honest dialogue and family relationships as well as the coming of age themes that define much of the “genre” (Family-Ties in New-Adult Fiction).
In terms of graphic novels, I did not grow up with the format and didn’t ever get into comics, but I have come to appreciate them. When I read Fun Home by Alison Bechdel (as the first adult graphic novel I read in its entirety), I found that I enjoyed the format for the first time as a way to read/tell a complete story. The library I worked at had an incredibly robust and popular collection of graphic novels and manga, divided into Y, J, and Adult collections. Each collection was well-used and promoted. I did most of the collecting for the juvenile graphic novels and found it to grow in popularity as we added more variety to the collection.
I have no problem recommending graphic novels to a patron of any age. I think they should be included in cross-format displays and reading lists as a way to encourage patrons to give them a try. Peoria Public Library partners with their community to choose a Peoria Reads book each year, and for 2019 that book is a graphic novel, Can’t We Talk About Something More Pleasant by Roz Chast. One the goals of Peoria Reads is to “Increase opportunities for discussion between youth and adults” and the format of this book is a vehicle to accomplish that (2019 Peoria Reads!). The title is a National Book Award Finalist and a NYT Bestseller. This is a perfect example of how a public library can introduce a well-reviewed graphic novel to their patrons and community.
References
2019 Peoria Reads! (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.peoriareads.org/goals.html
Cataldi, E. (2015). Betwixt and Between. Library Journal, 42-44.
Family-Ties in New-Adult Fiction. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.naalley.com/2013/07/match-5-lucas-1-vs-trent-17.html
New Adult literature is not a “genre” that I am yet well-versed in. I see the usefulness of it as a step beyond YA for those young adults who don’t want to read YA anymore (although, I think anyone can read good YA). The ability to differentiate between books about teens and books about young adults ages 18-26 is now a must, and being familiar with the most popular authors and series is something I will pay more attention to. I am anxious now to get my hands on a few titles so that I can explore the nuances of NA beyond the misconception that it is just about sex (Cataldi, 2015). NA Alley talks about the importance of honesty in these titles which translates to honest dialogue and family relationships as well as the coming of age themes that define much of the “genre” (Family-Ties in New-Adult Fiction).
In terms of graphic novels, I did not grow up with the format and didn’t ever get into comics, but I have come to appreciate them. When I read Fun Home by Alison Bechdel (as the first adult graphic novel I read in its entirety), I found that I enjoyed the format for the first time as a way to read/tell a complete story. The library I worked at had an incredibly robust and popular collection of graphic novels and manga, divided into Y, J, and Adult collections. Each collection was well-used and promoted. I did most of the collecting for the juvenile graphic novels and found it to grow in popularity as we added more variety to the collection.
I have no problem recommending graphic novels to a patron of any age. I think they should be included in cross-format displays and reading lists as a way to encourage patrons to give them a try. Peoria Public Library partners with their community to choose a Peoria Reads book each year, and for 2019 that book is a graphic novel, Can’t We Talk About Something More Pleasant by Roz Chast. One the goals of Peoria Reads is to “Increase opportunities for discussion between youth and adults” and the format of this book is a vehicle to accomplish that (2019 Peoria Reads!). The title is a National Book Award Finalist and a NYT Bestseller. This is a perfect example of how a public library can introduce a well-reviewed graphic novel to their patrons and community.
References
2019 Peoria Reads! (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.peoriareads.org/goals.html
Cataldi, E. (2015). Betwixt and Between. Library Journal, 42-44.
Family-Ties in New-Adult Fiction. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.naalley.com/2013/07/match-5-lucas-1-vs-trent-17.html
Hi Laura,
ReplyDeleteI totally understand your comment about 'the need to differenciate between books about teens and books about young adults ages 18-26 is now a must.' I work with a girl who is 23 and she is looking up all NA self help books for this age to help her cope with being a young adult. When I was this age most of my friends were married and had kids and were old married people. Today, I consider anyone between 21 and 40 as kids trying to find out who they are and their place in life. I know, because my 23 year old daughter still lives at home , works 3 parttime jobs and she is trying to find herself and the perfect fulltime job that she went to college for.
Hi Eugenie,
DeleteI think young adulthood has changed in the last couple of decades, so why shouldn't the literature surrounding it! I'm really interested in this nuance between YA and NA lit and plan to learn more about it so that I can recommend it to patrons.
Hi, Laura! I think you make some great points! I love that you ask them if they'd be open to YA suggestions - I think that's an awesome way to slide some out there when you can and give them a chance to possibly fall in love with a new book! I think part of the misconception about NA being "just about sex" is that a lot of the NA titles at first seemed to lean heavily that way. They have been getting away from that, thankfully. Not that it isn't there, still, but it's not *just* that. I've never been into Graphic Novels myself, but I have made sure to read a few every now and then just to keep myself apprised of the different offerings. I love that Peoria Reads chose a Graphic Novel for their book choice this year - that is awesome and definitely a great way to spread the love of Graphic Novels! :)
ReplyDeleteLaura,
ReplyDeleteIt is great that you are so into YA as a teen librarian. I think it is important to have people develop collections that they enjoy. While a good librarian can do collection development for any genre, there is a certain spark that is in a collection where the librarian loves the genre that they are developing.
Hi Laura,
ReplyDeleteCongrats on being promoted to Head of YS after just a few months! That's pretty amazing.
Fun Home was the first graphic novel I've read too! It actually piqued my interest and inspired me to read more works in this format. Something I like about graphic novels as a medium is that their plots always seem fast-paced to me. I wonder if people who enjoy fast-paced books would then enjoy graphic novels?
Great prompt response! I love that you don't shy away from asking people if they would like to hear a YA suggestion or two, it's a great way to expand their horizons! I'm glad you're opening up to NA and graphic novels as well. Kudos to you and full points!
ReplyDelete