Week Three Prompt Response
1. I am looking for a book by Laurell K. Hamilton. I just
read the third book in the Anita Blake series and I can’t figure out which one
comes next!
Novelist showed me
with a very quick “anita blake” search that the fourth book in the series is The Lunatic Cafe published in January 1996.
2. What have I read recently? Well, I just finished this great book by Barbara Kingsolver, Prodigal Summer. I really liked the way it was written, you know, the way she used language. I wouldn't mind something a bit faster paced though.
Searching Prodigal
Summer on Novelist produces some read alikes, one of which is Midwives by
Chris Bohjalian which I can personally attest is a well-written, faster paced
book. Another read alike is The History of Bees by Maja Lunde
which has an environmental/natural world theme that might resonate with someone
who enjoys Barbara Kingsolver. I would recommend both of those but also
take another step in Novelist and choose to limit to a lyrical writing style
and thought provoking tone for more Barbara Kingsolver read alikes. Doing
this gives me Future Home of the Living God by Louise Erdrich, a starred
review and award listed novel (Booklist Editors' Choice - Best Fiction Books:
2017, LibraryReads Favorites: 2017, New York Times Notable Books - Fiction and
Poetry: 2017). I have read some of Erdrich’s other novels and so can attest
that her writing is excellent.
3. I like reading books set in different countries. I just
read one set in China, could you help me find one set in Japan? No, not modern
– historical. I like it when the author describes it so much it feels like I
was there!
I searched my local
library catalog for Japan AND fiction AND history and found:
The Commoner by John Burnham Swartz - set in 1945 Japan, Subject
headings: women, nobility, Japan - History - 1945, Japan - social life and
customs.
This title has dozens
of copies of many different editions including large print and audio in the
SHARE system which indicates that, even though I am not familiar with it, it is
a popular title that is more likely to be interesting to the patron.
Another possibility:
The Scent of Sake by Joyce Lebra
4. I read this great mystery by Elizabeth George called
Well-Schooled in Murder and I loved it. Then my dentist said that if I liked
mysteries I would probably like John Sandford, but boy was he creepy I couldn't
finish it! Do you have any suggestions?
My first suggestion off-hand would be Louise
Penny. I would also recommend Alexander McCall Smith to someone who likes
mysteries but not anything creepy. Searching Novelist for read alikes for
mysteries with likeable characters (less likely to be creepy) gives me Sue
Grafton, Alexander McCall Smith (!), M.C. Beaton and… (drumroll) Elizabeth
George. I would recommend all of these authors to the patron.
5. My husband has really gotten into zombies lately. He’s
already read The Walking Dead and World War Z, is there anything else you can
recommend?
The difficulty here is
weeding through the juvenile and YA titles. Also, assuming he is not into
Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, I would start by asking the patron if
their husband would be open to any YA titles, as there are some good ones that
he might find satisfy the zombie theme. If the patron is 100% against the
idea of YA zombie titles…
Using Overbooked I
searched “zombies” and found Positive: A Novel by David
Wellington; it received several
starred reviews. The Overbooked synopsis states “Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome meets World War Z and I Am Legend
in this thrilling tale that has it all: a compelling story, great characters,
and explosive action, making Positive the ultimate zombie novel of our
time.” Ding, ding, ding...we have a potential winner!
If the patron is open
to any YA recommendations, I would start with The Forest of Hands and Teeth by
Carrie Ryan and also suggest The Chaos Walking trilogy by Patrick Ness (it’s
not about zombies but my husband who likes The Walking Dead enjoyed these).
6. I love books that get turned into movies, especially
literary ones. Can you recommend some? Nothing too old, maybe just those from
the last 5 years or so.
My top recommendation for a literary book
turned into a screen adaptation is Olive Kitteridge by Elizabeth Strout. It was a Pulitzer prize winning novel that aired as a limited HBO series
in late 2014. This recommendation comes
completely from my own experience with the book and the series.
To add another book to movie adaptation from the
past five years, I googled “literary book to movie adaptations”. Doing
this lead me pretty quickly to a 2018 PBS Books list of great book to movie
adaptations: http://www.pbs.org/book-view-now/blogs/news/2018/03/01/book-adaptations/ which would be a great resource for this patron! On the
list, Call Me by Your Name by Andre Aciman catches my eye first because
it got a lot of buzz last year and I can personally recommend it.
7. I love thrillers but I hate foul language and sex
scenes. I want something clean and fast paced.
I searched appeals in Novelist for the
following: fast-paced, intricately plotted, chaste. The following book
was offered: Run For Your Life by Jean Holbrook Mathews. Digging
further into the title tells me that it is Christian Suspense, which is just
about the only way you will get “clean” thrillers. If the patron agreed
that that title sounded like what they are looking for, I would also recommend
authors Lee Strobel, Ted Dekker, and Frank Peretti. These are authors
that I have experience recommending to patrons looking for Christian Suspense
novels.
****
As a ten-year veteran of full-time library work
without access to Novelist (sadly), my first go-to tool to answer RA questions
for which I don’t have an immediate answer is typically the library catalog.
If a patron wants a book NOW, that is the best bet. If a patron is willing to wait a week or two,
the catalog will still help us find books that are available in the system for
ILL purposes, but other resources can be consulted prior to requesting through
ILL. Boolean searches in the catalog and paying close attention to
subject headings used can help narrow down a difficult search.
Finding a title that seems like a good match to
the patron, you can then use Goodreads or Amazon to find similar titles (or
perhaps your library catalog has this feature, which is fantastic...when it
works!) Another clue: are there a lot of copies of this title in the
catalog? If yes, that means that even if
I am not familiar with the title, it is a popular book that is easily accessed
making it a better bet that a patron will be satisfied with it. Because this process has been my habit, I use it for myself, too!
I particularly tend to do this when searching the ebook portal (and I
tend to read ebooks just for convenience sake). I also read online reviews and follow releases
from different publications, publishing houses, and authors. Twitter is also helpful. When I was purchasing for kids and YA at the
library, I read SLJ and Kirkus reviews pretty religiously.
I explored Overbooked.com for this assignment
(one of Chelton’s recommendations) and find it to be somewhat useful and
charming but not as robust as Novelist. Novelist’s Make Your Own Appeal
Mix feature is really amazing, and their read alikes are pretty spot on. The extra resources available for RA for
librarians and patrons both are pretty hard to beat. I don’t know what
the yearly cost is, but any library with enough funding should be providing
access to Novelist for their staff and patrons.
Thank you so much for finding and sharing that PBS article! I really struggled with that question. I think I was caught up on the "only 5 years old" part and also on what exactly a "literary" title is. Saricks book helped provide me with a workable definition, but I feel like "literary" is so subjective to people and it honestly isn't a category I read a lot of. I also recommended the History of Bees for question 2 but I like that you took it a step further and found an award winning title that features minority characters. Excellent work!
ReplyDeleteHi Caitlyn, I found Novelist to be so helpful and enjoyed using it for some of these questions (like number 2). For question 5, my gut told me to google ...that is what I would do first if I had the patron in front of me with this same question. And I find that when people quantify something like "only 5 years old" they are often still open to other answers that could be 7 or 10 years old. Breaking the request down into the "must do" part (movies from books) and the "would be nice" parts (only 5 years old) helps me a lot.
DeleteHey Caitlyn and Laura! Chelton had a great source in her list - a Based on the Book site that I used to help with #6 (when looking the 5 year old part, although I was struggling with "is the movie or the book supposed to be five or so years old?" HAHA. But with a "real" patron you have them to ask, so there's that. And literary can be subjective, so I did what you did, Caitlyn, and just went with Saricks' definition!).
Deletehttps://www.mymcpl.org/books-movies-music/read/based-on-the-book
This is great, Brandy! Thank you!
DeleteHow hard is it for you all to recommend books you yourself hated? I really did not like Olive Kitteridge when I read it and I can imagine being reluctant to recommend it (although knowing if they are looking for the world's most depressing novel- I'm sure I could easily recommend it!). It's so much easier to recommend books you enjoyed (but not always helpful to the patron!)! Great insight in your search techniques, Laura!
ReplyDeleteOlive Kitteridge is not everyone's cup of tea, to be sure. I enjoyed it as a character study, and Strout's writing style is one that I like. I think we all come to RA with our own biases. I am not a fan of sci-fi, so that would be a stretch for me to recommend much in that genre. That's where Novelist and other tools come in to bridge the gap!
DeleteExcellent responses, you did a great job outlining how you used different resources for each question and came up with great responses! Full points!
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed your book recommendations for each question within the assignment, especially the History of Bees for finding a story similair to the one by Klingsover. I have skimmed the book in the past, as I was fascinated by all bee related books that were both fiction and non-fiction, as I had just started beekeeping and was enjoying "natural and environmental" storylines.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I really enjoy this blog layout, wonderful job! It is very professional in design and easy for an individual to browse and find the appropriate assignment for review. Good work.